Is homemade GOP ad attacking Socialism in America the best political ad this election?

October 31, 2012

“The Rich will be Poorer, But the Poor will also be Poorer.”

Rarely does a political ad rise above it’s own hubris or brazen loyalties. We’re seeing scores of them now for myriad candidates and propositions. And, no surprise, most of them stink. Typically, we get a montage of photographs and a sullen script about promises not kept by the opponent and/or new promises being made by the other. Most ads stoop lower. In the end it’s always the same.

But there are exceptions. Hal Riney’s famous “It’s Morning Again in America” for Ronald Reagan. Or Lyndon Johnson’s epic scare-fest, “Daisy” in 1964. These are significant pieces of work that arguably changed the election for both advertisers.

I’m not suggesting the above ad for the GOP rises to those levels but it aims to. The spot opens with an older man, Thomas Peterffy telling us “I grew up in a socialist country…” He then goes on to say why he came to America, rhapsodizing about the American Dream and its wealth “coming from people striving for success.” You see where this is going. If you haven’t already seen the ad on TV, watch it. Watch it again.

Yes, the music and imagery are pedantic. And yes, it’s pure propaganda. But the fact isn’t the facts: It’s the story. And the story is riveting. Whether Mr. Peterffy is right or wrong doesn’t matter. He believes he is right. And his argument is unwavering as it is stoic. When he infers that under President Obama “The rich will be poorer, but the poor will also be poorer” we are thunderstruck. I was anyway. This is the kind of message Clint “The Chair” Eastwood should have made at the Republican National Convention. It’s scary good rhetoric. Playing on the latent –perhaps very latent- DNA of every American. In other words, Peterffy strikes a “responsive chord.” Remember those?

Frankly, I don’t like where either political party is going right now. But this isn’t about me or the candidates. I want only to discuss the above ad from the point of view of an observer of popular culture and as a copywriter.

Politically, I’m numb. For all I know Petterfy’s ad is merely preaching to the converted. It won’t change me. But it did make me pause. It’s the only ad in this election year that has.

“It’s Morning Again in America”



7 Responses to “Is homemade GOP ad attacking Socialism in America the best political ad this election?”

  1. Jeff said

    Good post, Steffan. All these political ads reminded me of this excellent bit from “Mr. Show.” So funny… and great levity.

    Watch it here:

    -jeff norman

  2. This made-in-America billionaire truly sees a parallel between post war Hungary and modern day America? I don’t think so. The only parallel is the widespread use of propaganda.

    The fear of a Socialist America is purely a fabrication. Even our most devout leftists like to make a good living and enjoy the fruits of their labor.

    • Steffan1 said

      I agree this guy may be off his nut but the rhetoric and delivery of it is pretty riveting.
      And I do love the line about poor getting poorer…
      Thanks for comment, SP

  3. […] creative director, Steffan Postaer, thinks Peterffy’s ad above is well […]

  4. David Feinberg said

    I found this page while trying to find out exactly which “socialist” country he came from. So it’s Hungary? That was a Communist country, or are we to believe that Socialists, Communists and Liberal Democrats all one and the same? And if the poor get poorer, why does the US lag behind liberal Western European societies in upward mobility?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: