What does the “UPS Whiteboard Guy” and a Canadian musician have in common? Bad airline service and using social media for retribution.

July 17, 2009

images-1
Or you can bitch online…

You’re all aware of the Canadian musician, Dave Carroll who wrote a song about United Airlines trashing his guitar, made a video, and posted it on You Tube.

United Hurt My Guitar

The song is mediocre but, like they say, it’s the thought that counts. Big thought. Last I checked well over 2 million people have watched the video! I experienced part of it on the 6 o’clock news. Even United Airlines is a fan, claiming to want the thing for future training reasons. Yeah, right. My guess is they’re feigning humility to mitigate scorn. (What I’d do.)

Either way, both parties have settled. Presumably United will be more careful with how they handle luggage. Presumably. And our Canadian friend got himself those precious moments of fame Andy Warhol made famous. I bet his band gets a lot more bookings and, if nothing else, the musician now has something for the scrapbook.

Now let’s talk about the kafuffle involving the self-named “UPS Whiteboard Actor” and Delta Airlines. After experiencing a brutal 24 hours trying to get his family from Richmond to Atlanta, the actor/creative director, Andy Azula wrote an angry post on his blog, detailing the nightmare, and vowing never to fly Delta again unless he receives some form of recompense, be it material or an apology or both. The missive was picked up by other trade blogs including Agency Spy:

adman_cries_at_delta_has_principles_121695.asp

Dozens of comments quickly followed, most calling the guy a whiner and a poser and a bunch of other things. Many ridiculed Andy’s odd long hair, a trademark of sorts. To be fair, the comments on his own blog were mostly in support of the “article.” Read for yourself.

UPS Guy vs. Delta Airlines

Both events have two things in common: bad airline service and using social media to seek retribution. But while the musician is getting lots of love the UPS guy is taking a fair amount of abuse. There are probably many reasons for this discrepancy but the main one is obvious. The unknown musician made a charming video about his ordeal while the somewhat known Azula just bitched.

As a creative director and blogger, I empathize with Andy. I, too, have wanted retribution for one thing or another. I like having a forum, albeit minuscule. However, having learned the hard way, I also recognize the potential for self-made sparks to ignite online. Certain topics and/or the way we communicate them… We think we are being insightful but we are perceived as inciting. We think we are being provocative but we are only provoking. Andy must have crossed a line.

I’m as sensitive to barrages of criticism as the next guy. I don’t like it. Yet my best advice for Azula is to take it on the chin. He got the letter out of his system. Now it lives on drawing ire. Let it go, my longhaired buddy. Fighting Internet snipers is even harder than taking on an airline!

At the time of this writing, the Zappos RFP fiasco was breaking. Here, the creative director at small shop, Ignited took out his frustration online with regard to being unfairly dismissed by Zappos unwieldy pitch process. Once again, the trade blogs reported it and the trolls feasted. Much debate about these issues could and should be had. Lord knows pitching new business has become ridiculous, with lots of blame to go around. But are social networks the place to have it?

Steff\'s Twitter

8 Responses to “What does the “UPS Whiteboard Guy” and a Canadian musician have in common? Bad airline service and using social media for retribution.”

  1. Van Gould said

    I get annoyed by all the social network bitching. Everybody does it. Wow, I just realized I am bitching about the bitching right now. I think social networks are a great place for creative complaining though. Perhaps we should give our grievances a few more rounds of concepting before posting them online?

  2. ANONYMOUS said

    >>>>I like having a forum, albeit miniscule.<<<<
    MAYBE YOUR FORUM WOULD BE LESS MINUSCULE IF YOU USED SPELL-CHECK AND WROTE A LITTLE BETTER.

  3. SRP said

    Thank you Anon, for the spell check.
    Sorry for your anger issues.😉

  4. azula’s letter was over the top–you would think delta killed his kids or something. like too many ad folks he has lost perspective on what real troubles are. next he’ll be writing a diatribe because he didn’t get an ocean view room at shutters.

    but the real kicker was that he actually signed the note “ups whiteboard actor”–unfuckingbelievable.

    if i were the martin agency i would immediately fire azula and hire the guy who did the united film.

  5. Jim-

    I wonder if Azula took any heat from his agency & client for the attention his letter brought him/them. If/when this blog ever draws unwanted attention for my agency/clients…

  6. i’m sure he did. you’re not really supposed to sign your company name to letters like that. his entire note is an example of what not to do in these types of situations. of course, that haircut of his is a dead giveaway that he has serious judgement issues.

  7. Oh boy said

    Already this is being written about as ‘UPS vs Delta.’ This guy has used his CLIENTs name to sign his letter. Maybe Delta does business with UPS? Maybe they won’t any more. Write your letter. Leave your agencys name out of it. But God almighty, leave your clients name out of it. He seemed to be using the name UPS to get attention, as if he represents them. Martin should be worried.

  8. Glowlymaymn said

    This looks cool so far, what’s up people?
    If there’s anyone else here, let me know.
    Oh, and yes I’m a real person LOL.

    Peace,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: